DataBreaches.Net

Menu
  • About
  • Breach Notification Laws
  • Privacy Policy
  • Transparency Report
Menu

Consumer Watchdog Asks HHS to Repeal Rule Allowing Health Care Providers to Decide When Notification of Breached Electronic Medical Records is Necessary

Posted on October 22, 2009 by Dissent

Consumer Watchdog today called on the Health and Human Services Department to repeal a rule that allows health care providers and insurers to decide whether consumers must be notified when the security of their electronic confidential health information has been breached.

In a letter to HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius the nonprofit, nonpartisan consumer advocacy group said the HHS regulation violated the intent of Congress when it charged the department with writing the rules requiring notification if electronic medical records are breached. Consumers must be notified whenever there is a breach of medical records, the group said.

The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA) requires notification if there is an “unauthorized acquisition, access, use, or disclosure of protected health information which compromises the security or privacy of such information.” The act charged HHS with writing and implementing the rules. But HHS decided to interpret “compromises the security” of data to include a substantial harm standard.

“Under the HHS interpretation, if the breaching entity decides there is no significant risk of financial, reputation or other harm to the individual, the provider or health insurer never has to disclose that the sensitive information was used or disclosed in violation of the federal privacy rule,” wrote John M. Simpson, consumer advocate. “In other words, the company responsible for protecting the sensitive data gets to decide if it needs to bother to tell anyone that sensitive health data was breached. This is simply outrageous.”

Consumer Watchdog asked what prompted HHS to flout Congressional intent. “Could it be that Congress managed to fend off the pressures of the health care industry in passing ARRA only to have the lobbyists return to exert their influence on the rule making process?”

Read Consumer Watchdog’s letter here:
https://www.consumerwatchdog.org/resources/LtrSebelius102209.pdf

Consumer Watchdog noted that Rep. Henry Waxman, Rep. Charles B. Rangel, Rep. John Dingell, Rep. Frank Pallone Jr., Rep. Pete Fortney Stark and Rep. Joe Barton have written Secretary Sebelius protesting that the HHS rule violates Congressional intent. The Congressmen’s letter said:

“The primary purpose for mandatory breach notification is to provide incentives for health care entities to protect data, such as through strong encryption or destruction methodologies and to allow individuals to assess the level of unauthorized use of disclosure of their information. Such transparency allows the consumer to judge the quality of a health care entity’s privacy protection based on how many breaches occur, enabling them to choose entities with better privacy practices. Furthermore, a black and white standard makes implementation and enforcement simpler.”

Read the Congressional letter here:
https://www.consumerwatchdog.org/resources/LtrCongSebelius.pdf

Consumer Watchdog said that the Federal Trade Commission, charged with writing breach regulations for non-HIPPA covered entities such as Personal Health Records vendors like Google Health did not find any justification for introducing a “harm” standard. “The FTC remained true to Congressional intent and to promoting the public interest,” the letter said.

Related posts:

  • Aetna, still looking for scapegoat in HIV disclosure fiasco, sues plaintiffs firms
  • HHS Office for Civil Rights Imposes a $240,000 Civil Monetary Penalty Against Providence Medical Institute in HIPAA Ransomware Cybersecurity Investigation
  • Victims of W-2 phishing scams (2017 list)
  • FTC Finalizes Changes to the Health Breach Notification Rule
Category: Breach LawsCommentaries and AnalysesFederalLegislationOf Note

Post navigation

← EXCLUSIVE: UW-Madison discovers 40 computers used for file-sharing
House passes bill excluding small healthcare practices from Red Flag Rules →

Now more than ever

"Stand with Ukraine:" above raised hands. The illustration is in blue and yellow, the colors of Ukraine's flag.

Search

Browse by Categories

Recent Posts

  • Texas Centers for Infectious Disease Associates Notifies Individuals of Data Breach in 2024
  • Battlefords Union Hospitals notifies patients of employee snooping in their records
  • Alert: Scattered Spider has added North American airline and transportation organizations to their target list
  • Northern Light Health patients affected by security incident at Compumedics; 10 healthcare entities affected
  • Privacy commissioner reviewing reported Ontario Health atHome data breach
  • CMS warns Medicare providers of fraud scheme
  • Ex-student charged with wave of cyber attacks on Sydney uni
  • Detaining Hackers Before the Crime? Tamil Nadu’s Supreme Court Approves Preventive Custody for Cyber Offenders
  • Potential Cyberattack Scrambles Columbia University Computer Systems
  • 222,000 customer records allegedly from Manhattan Parking Group leaked

No, You Can’t Buy a Post or an Interview

This site does not accept sponsored posts or link-back arrangements. Inquiries about either are ignored.

And despite what some trolls may try to claim: DataBreaches has never accepted even one dime to interview or report on anyone. Nor will DataBreaches ever pay anyone for data or to interview them.

Want to Get Our RSS Feed?

Grab it here:

https://databreaches.net/feed/

RSS Recent Posts on PogoWasRight.org

  • Germany Wants Apple, Google to Remove DeepSeek From Their App Stores
  • Supreme Court upholds Texas law requiring age verification on porn sites
  • Justices nix Medicaid ‘right’ to choose doctor, defunding Planned Parenthood in South Carolina
  • European Commission publishes its plan to enable more effective law enforcement access to data
  • Sacred Secrets: The Biblical Case for Privacy and Data Protection
  • Microsoft’s Departing Privacy Chief Calls for Regulator Outreach
  • Nestle USA Settles Suit Over Job-Application Medical Questions

Have a News Tip?

Email: Tips[at]DataBreaches.net

Signal: +1 516-776-7756

Contact Me

Email: info[at]databreaches.net

Mastodon: Infosec.Exchange/@PogoWasRight

Signal: +1 516-776-7756

DMCA Concern: dmca[at]databreaches.net
© 2009 – 2025 DataBreaches.net and DataBreaches LLC. All rights reserved.