DataBreaches.Net

Menu
  • About
  • Breach Notification Laws
  • Privacy Policy
  • Transparency Report
Menu

Who Owns Your Dead Son’s Brain?

Posted on August 24, 2010 by Dissent

Over on The Volokh Conspiracy, Jonathan H. Adler writes:

Do parents have a constitutionally protected property interest in the dead body of their child, including all organs?  Not necessarily is the answer given by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit in Albrecht v. Treon, at least under Ohio law as interpreted by the Ohio Supreme Court.

The Albrechts brought a Section 1983 suit against the county coroner, among others, alleging that they were deprived of a protected property interest without due process of law when the coroner removed and retained their dead son’s brain without notice.  According to the state, the brain was needed for additional study to aid in a criminal investigation. The question was certified to the Ohio Supreme Court, which held that under Ohio law the parents have no constitutionally protected interest in their child’s human remains that are retained for criminal investigation purposes, prompting a judgment for the state in district court.  Today, the Sixth Circuit affirmed, distinguishing Circuit precedent that recognized constitutionally protected property interests in a family member’s body parts retained for donation purposes.

There is something disturbing to me about treating body parts as property, and I wonder if that is really the only viable legal analysis or approach. Our society seems to understand the emotional need of families to bury even fragments of their dead and to have that solace or comfort, and yet decisions about whether states have to notify family members of parts removed or offer them the opportunity to make their own arrangements for burial or disposal after any forensic examinations are completed is seemingly left to the states as a matter of property law.

Ugh.

A legal analysis of the case written back in 2007 provides some background and discussion of the issues.

Category: Uncategorized

Post navigation

← AU: Hacker hits Ballarat City Council files
NZ: Health Ministry seized 30,000 patient files →

2 thoughts on “Who Owns Your Dead Son’s Brain?”

  1. Anonymous says:
    August 25, 2010 at 5:48 pm

    Medical examiners working on a criminal case can help solve those cases and help pin evidence on the responsible party for a death. I believe the state has the right to hold onto a body part for investigation in a criminal case. HOWEVER, the family should be given a choice to bury the remaining parts now or wait until the full body is provided to them for burial.

    1. Anonymous says:
      August 25, 2010 at 6:13 pm

      There was no issue as to whether the coroner had any right to retain the parts to use for forensic examination as required by state law. The only issue is what happens to the body parts after the examination and testing is completed.

      I wonder how many people reading about this case will suddenly wonder whether they really buried their loved one’s entire body or not.

      A very unsettling case.

Comments are closed.

Now more than ever

"Stand with Ukraine:" above raised hands. The illustration is in blue and yellow, the colors of Ukraine's flag.

Search

Browse by Categories

Recent Posts

  • Masimo Manufacturing Facilities Hit by Cyberattack
  • Education giant Pearson hit by cyberattack exposing customer data
  • Star Health hacker claims sending bullets, threats to top executives: Reports
  • Nova Scotia Power hit by cyberattack, critical infrastructure targeted, no outages reported
  • Georgia hospital defeats data-tracking lawsuit
  • 60K BTC Wallets Tied to LockBit Ransomware Gang Leaked
  • UK: Legal Aid Agency hit by cyber security incident
  • Public notice for individuals affected by an information security breach in the Social Services, Health Care and Rescue Services Division of Helsinki
  • PowerSchool paid a hacker’s extortion demand, but now school district clients are being extorted anyway (3)
  • Defending Against UNC3944: Cybercrime Hardening Guidance from the Frontlines

No, You Can’t Buy a Post or an Interview

This site does not accept sponsored posts or link-back arrangements. Inquiries about either are ignored.

And despite what some trolls may try to claim: DataBreaches has never accepted even one dime to interview or report on anyone. Nor will DataBreaches ever pay anyone for data or to interview them.

Want to Get Our RSS Feed?

Grab it here:

https://databreaches.net/feed/

RSS Recent Posts on PogoWasRight.org

  • The App Store Freedom Act Compromises User Privacy To Punish Big Tech
  • Florida bill requiring encryption backdoors for social media accounts has failed
  • Apple Siri Eavesdropping Payout Deadline Confirmed—How To Make A Claim
  • Privacy matters to Canadians – Privacy Commissioner of Canada marks Privacy Awareness Week with release of latest survey results
  • Missouri Clinic Must Give State AG Minor Trans Care Information
  • Georgia hospital defeats data-tracking lawsuit
  • No Postal Service Data Sharing to Deport Immigrants

Have a News Tip?

Email: Tips[at]DataBreaches.net

Signal: +1 516-776-7756

Contact Me

Email: info[at]databreaches.net

Mastodon: Infosec.Exchange/@PogoWasRight

Signal: +1 516-776-7756

DMCA Concern: dmca[at]databreaches.net
© 2009 – 2025 DataBreaches.net and DataBreaches LLC. All rights reserved.