DataBreaches.Net

Menu
  • About
  • Breach Notification Laws
  • Privacy Policy
  • Transparency Report
Menu

NJ: Grieving mother wants law to protect privacy of accident victims

Posted on November 16, 2011 by Dissent

Nora Muchanic of WPVI reports that a distraught New Jersey mother is fighting for legislation that would spare others the anguish she experienced when a first responder uploaded crash photos of her daughter’s accident online before she even knew that her daughter had been in a fatal crash.

Cathy Bates, 40, was killed in a head-on crash on Route 72 in Barnegat back in 2009.

While first responders were trying to save her, a member of the Pinewood Estates Volunteer Fire Company snapped pictures of her inside the car and posted the photos on Facebook.

Those pictures were published before Cathy’s family even knew she’d been in an accident.

“To take these pictures and post them on your personal website and make hard copies and show them around… This is unacceptable,” said Cathy’s mother, Lucille.

The photos were quickly taken down. The fire chief says there were no close-ups and the person who took the pictures has left the department.

Muchanic reports that the proposed law would prohibit first responders from taking graphic images at a scene and sharing them without the consent of the victim’s family. Violators could face fines and jail.

Read more on WPVI.

This is certainly not the first time I’ve reported a case like this involving first responders. I’ve previously noted cases involving the Umatilla Fire Department, the City of Casa Grande case, and the  and the Clinton-Hickman County Ambulance Service case as a few examples. And as I’ve noted in the past, there are a number of issues here. Some first responder units – but not all – are HIPAA-covered entities, so HIPAA’s privacy protections apply and no additional law should be needed. But what about non-covered entities?  In some cases, they may have their own policies, but violation of those policies would not be enforceable criminally. Should any proposed state law mirror federal consequences for violations?

Problematically from a privacy standpoint, most of these accidents happen in public spaces and it has been hammered into our heads that we have no reasonable expectation of privacy in public spaces. HIPAA-covered entities who respond to the public accident scene are still under HIPAA’s obligations, but what about everyone else?  Can you criminalize taking photos in a public space?  Will you say that reporters on the scene of an accident cannot take pictures, too?  Collisions can be terrible. In this case, we may have a collision between privacy interests and the First Amendment.  Can a state really enact such legislation that can withstand a constitutional challenge?  I tend to doubt it, even though I am sympathetic to the privacy issues and wish that more people showed self-restraint.

Okay, you argue, what about using such photos for training purposes?  Could such photos be helpful to emergency medical personnel in their courses?  Possibly, even probably for some situations. In my own emergency medical training, we were shown photos from real cases (although most of those photos were taken in a morgue).  But if it is okay to use photos of real cases in that context, then is it just one small slippery step to say that posting them on the Internet is being done for educational or training purposes for a broader audience?

So what’s the solution if we can’t give everyone a sense of decency or self-restraint?

My preference would be to bring all public emergency response units – including police, volunteer ambulance corps, and fire departments under HIPAA so that they would be bound by its privacy protections.  What do you think?

h/t,   Kirsch Gartenberg Howard LLP.

Category: Health Data

Post navigation

← PA: Names and Social Security numbers of Public School Employees’ Retirement System members exposed on Internet
IL: Social Security numbers are disclosed on mailings to participants in Bright Directions college savings program →

Now more than ever

"Stand with Ukraine:" above raised hands. The illustration is in blue and yellow, the colors of Ukraine's flag.

Search

Browse by Categories

Recent Posts

  • PowerSchool hacker pleads guilty, released on personal recognizance bond
  • Rewards for Justice offers $10M reward for info on RedLine developer or RedLine’s use by foreign governments
  • New evidence links long-running hacking group to Indian government
  • Zaporizhzhia Cyber ​​Police Exposes Hacker Who Caused Millions in Losses to Victims by Mining Cryptocurrency
  • Germany fines Vodafone $51 million for privacy, security breaches
  • Google: Hackers target Salesforce accounts in data extortion attacks
  • The US Grid Attack Looming on the Horizon
  • US govt login portal could be one cyberattack away from collapse, say auditors
  • Two Men Sentenced to Prison for Aggravated Identity Theft and Computer Hacking Crimes
  • 100,000 UK taxpayer accounts hit in £47m phishing attack on HMRC

No, You Can’t Buy a Post or an Interview

This site does not accept sponsored posts or link-back arrangements. Inquiries about either are ignored.

And despite what some trolls may try to claim: DataBreaches has never accepted even one dime to interview or report on anyone. Nor will DataBreaches ever pay anyone for data or to interview them.

Want to Get Our RSS Feed?

Grab it here:

https://databreaches.net/feed/

RSS Recent Posts on PogoWasRight.org

  • How the FBI Sought a Warrant to Search Instagram of Columbia Student Protesters
  • Germany fines Vodafone $51 million for privacy, security breaches
  • Malaysia enacts data sharing rules for public sector
  • U.S. Enacts Take It Down Act
  • 23andMe Bankruptcy Judge Ponders Trump Bill’s Injunction Impact
  • Hell No: The ODNI Wants to Make it Easier for the Government to Buy Your Data Without Warrant
  • US State Dept. says silence or anonymity on social media is suspicious

Have a News Tip?

Email: Tips[at]DataBreaches.net

Signal: +1 516-776-7756

Contact Me

Email: info[at]databreaches.net

Mastodon: Infosec.Exchange/@PogoWasRight

Signal: +1 516-776-7756

DMCA Concern: dmca[at]databreaches.net
© 2009 – 2025 DataBreaches.net and DataBreaches LLC. All rights reserved.