DataBreaches.Net

Menu
  • About
  • Breach Notification Laws
  • Privacy Policy
  • Transparency Report
Menu

Buying Breached Data: When Is It Ethical?

Posted on April 3, 2021 by Dissent

Jeremy Kirk reports:

Security practitioners often tread a fine and not entirely well-defined legal line when conducting data breach research. This research can also pose ethical questions when commercial sources for stolen data fall into a gray area.

Kirk’s article on DataBreach Today provides a good overview of the issue.  And I totally agree with Troy Hunt on this issue, who is quoted as saying:

“I can’t for the life of me understand how security companies paying for that data on a legal basis is any different than the hacker buying the data,” he says. “People justifying this practice are relying entirely on intent being the differentiating factor, but that doesn’t do anything to de-incentivize the market for stolen data.”

I know there are people who maintain that once a data dump has been made public, it’s fair game, and people can buy it and use it.  But if you buy it — even if you pay for it in “tokens” on RF — you are encouraging more data theft and dumps, which harms consumer privacy.  This applies even in those situations where a firm or individual is buying a data dump on behalf of the victim company who wants to find out what data the threat actors obtained. Their agent is not doing anything technically wrong or illegal (at least I don’t think they are) but by making the purchase for them, they are still rewarding the criminals with a payment and therefore still encouraging crime.

Even if you just download the data totally for free but then use it on your commercial site — like charging people to access the data that you did not have the owner’s consent to obtain or use —  well, to me, that’s unethical if not actually illegal.

 

Related posts:

  • The Myth of Jurisdictional Privacy
Category: Commentaries and Analyses

Post navigation

← SG: Vhive attackers escalate, take control of furniture retailer’s email server
Phone numbers for 533 million Facebook users leaked on hacking forum →

Now more than ever

"Stand with Ukraine:" above raised hands. The illustration is in blue and yellow, the colors of Ukraine's flag.

Search

Browse by Categories

Recent Posts

  • Alert: Scattered Spider has added North American airline and transportation organizations to their target list
  • Northern Light Health patients affected by security incident at Compumedics; 10 healthcare entities affected
  • Privacy commissioner reviewing reported Ontario Health atHome data breach
  • CMS warns Medicare providers of fraud scheme
  • Ex-student charged with wave of cyber attacks on Sydney uni
  • Detaining Hackers Before the Crime? Tamil Nadu’s Supreme Court Approves Preventive Custody for Cyber Offenders
  • Potential Cyberattack Scrambles Columbia University Computer Systems
  • 222,000 customer records allegedly from Manhattan Parking Group leaked
  • Breaches have consequences (sometimes) (1)
  • Kansas City Man Pleads Guilty for Hacking a Non-Profit

No, You Can’t Buy a Post or an Interview

This site does not accept sponsored posts or link-back arrangements. Inquiries about either are ignored.

And despite what some trolls may try to claim: DataBreaches has never accepted even one dime to interview or report on anyone. Nor will DataBreaches ever pay anyone for data or to interview them.

Want to Get Our RSS Feed?

Grab it here:

https://databreaches.net/feed/

RSS Recent Posts on PogoWasRight.org

  • Germany Wants Apple, Google to Remove DeepSeek From Their App Stores
  • Supreme Court upholds Texas law requiring age verification on porn sites
  • Justices nix Medicaid ‘right’ to choose doctor, defunding Planned Parenthood in South Carolina
  • European Commission publishes its plan to enable more effective law enforcement access to data
  • Sacred Secrets: The Biblical Case for Privacy and Data Protection
  • Microsoft’s Departing Privacy Chief Calls for Regulator Outreach
  • Nestle USA Settles Suit Over Job-Application Medical Questions

Have a News Tip?

Email: Tips[at]DataBreaches.net

Signal: +1 516-776-7756

Contact Me

Email: info[at]databreaches.net

Mastodon: Infosec.Exchange/@PogoWasRight

Signal: +1 516-776-7756

DMCA Concern: dmca[at]databreaches.net
© 2009 – 2025 DataBreaches.net and DataBreaches LLC. All rights reserved.